iPod Touch + Nokia N82 > iPhone 3G

A while ago I wrote about why it did not make sense for me to buy an iPhone 3G in India, and why I purchased a Nokia N82 instead. However, a combination of the N82 and the iPod Touch is a different matter altogether. It costs about the same as the iPhone in India and offers a far, far better overall experience.

In a nutshell, iPod Touch is iPhone without the phone, SMS, camera and Bluetooth. Which is great, because those were the very features that iPhone was criticized for. Fortunately, the N82 excels at all of these. Here’s my take on using the 16GB iPod Touch and the Nokia N82.

Price

8GB iPod Touch + 2GB Nokia N82 = Rs. 17000 + Rs. 19000 = Rs. 36000. 8GB iPhone = Rs. 31000.
16GB iPod Touch + 2GB Nokia N82 = Rs. 22000 + Rs. 19000 = Rs. 41000. 16GB iPhone = Rs. 36000.

So the combination costs Rs. 5000 more than the equivalent iPhone. We’ll see what you get in return for that amount of extra money.

Connecting the iPod Touch to the Internet via the N82

The chief difference between the Touch and its iPod predecessors is Wifi. This transforms the Touch from a music and video player into a full-fledged Internet access device that also happens to do music and video. In fact, there’s evidence to show that iPod Touch owners rarely use the device for music. The corollary is that if you don’t have a Wifi signal, your iPod Touch is little more than a very expensive iPod with (comparatively) tiny amounts of storage.

Enter Joikuspot. This marvelous application converts your GPRS/EDGE/3G-capable Nokia phone into a WiFi hotspot. Most recent Nseries and Eseries phones have Wifi capability, including the N82. This means that I can connect to the Internet by simply selecting the N82 Wifi hotspot from my iPod Touch.

This give your iPod Touch a whole new lease of life. No mobile device matches the Internet experience on an iPhone/iPod Touch. I can’t quantify this, but mobile Safari renders pages in a way that makes the Internet connection seem faster than on the N82 browser.

Finally, the $9.95 iPod Touch software upgrade gives you access to the iPhone App Store, where you can install anything ranging from the Twitterific twitter client to the New York Times news reader app, to iPhone WordPress client to literally hundreds of free and paid applications and games.

What’s better on the N82

The N82 does a splendid job at whatever the iPhone is poor at. The best example is the superb 5MP camera with autofocus, Carl Zeiss optics and Xenon flash. The camera can also record videos at up to 30 frames per second. Check out the quality of photos and videos from the N82 on my Flickr stream.

I can use Bluetooth on the N82 to transfer files, sync with my PC over the air and pair with hands-free headsets. The crippled iPhone Bluetooth implementation only does headset pairing. Nothing else. The N82 can be used as a modem for my PC. For reasons unknown, iPhone cannot do this. The only third-party app that could do this was pulled from the App Store within a day. The N82 also supports copy-and-paste and can forward text messages, features inexplicably left out of iPhone.

There are thousands of S60 applications that aren’t part of the iPhone App Store. Nokia’s Sports Tracker and Nokia’s Map Loader come immediately to mind, as does Fring (which only runs on jailbroken iPhones/iPods Touch).

Finally, there have been no reported performance issues with the N82 3G chip. Not so for iPhone, that has had issues so severe with the onboard 3G chip that it has spawned rumors of a handset recall.

What’s better on the iPod Touch

Internet Experience, iPhone App Store – I’ve already spoken about this earlier. Once you’ve experienced the Internet on iPhone/iPod Touch, nothing – nothing – will make you go back to any other mobile device. Its crisp colors, smooth fonts, elegant multi-touch controls are streets ahead of the competition.

The iPod Touch is also a very elegant, capable PDA, comprising Contacts, Calendar (with support for multiple calendars), Tasks and a Mail client capable of displaying rich text/HTML. The Contacts and Calendar sync with Outlook. The Mail client, in addition to supporting POP3 and IMAP accounts, can also connect to a corporate Microsoft Exchange setup.

Lest we forget, the iPod Touch is also an iPod. With 8GB or 16GB of storage, it can hold a big chunk of most music collections. Because of the high-quality display, video playback is exquisite – you forget you’re using a mobile device. Videos also begin playing from the point you left off last time. And yes, almost as a footnote, it’s great for viewing large photo collections too. The iPod Touch multimedia experience is a generation ahead of what the N82 offers.

Conclusion

For Rs. 5000 and one gadget extra, you a great camera, video recording, functional Bluetooth, functional SMS, 2GB extra storage, ability to use your GPRS/EDGE/3G connection from your computer, access to thousands of S60 apps and reliable 3G. As with the iPhone you also get a top-of-the-line PDA and a gorgeous multimedia device.

Sounds like a good deal? To me, it was a no-brainer. What do you think?